| Fr. Mark O'Keefe, OSB | 1996 - 2008 |
| Fr. Eugene Hensell, OSB | 1987 - 1996 |
| Fr. Daniel Buechlein, OSB | 1971 - 1987 |
| Fr. Adrian Fuerst, OSB | 1969 - 1971 |
| Fr. Conrad Louis, OSB | 1966 - 1969 |
| Fr. Theodore Heck, OSB | 1956 - 1966 |
| Fr. Conrad Louis, OSB | 1951 - 1956 |
| Fr. Anselm Schaaf, OSB | 1931 - 1951 |
| Fr. Columban Thuis, OSB | 1930 - 1931 |
| Fr. Albert Kleber, OSB | 1917 - 1930 |
| Fr. Gregory Bechtold, OSB | 1902 - 1917 |
| Fr. Augustine Seiler, OSB | 1899 - 1902 |
| Fr. Gregory Bechtold, OSB | 1898 - 1899 |
| Fr. Athanasius Schmitt, OSB | 1895 - 1898 |
| Fr. Isidor Hobi, OSB | 1861 - 1895 |